In 2016 we found out about the Light2Learn project School Run 2017, which will install solar power at a number of schools in the Atlas Mountains in Morocco. Since then, we have been planning and organizing our lives so we could join this project. We will be driving from Sweden to Morocco (and back) in my 1999 Toyota Land Cruiser 100 during the autumn of 2017.

Wednesday, September 6, 2017

GPS-applications to use when traveling

Since there doesn't seem to be a good summary of good GPS apps, I have made one for different GPS programs to use with my Nexus 7 Sony Z4 Tablet (Android) and iPad 2 together with a Garmin GLO.

I generously received a Sony Xperia Z4 Tablet as sponsorship for our project. The tablet was mounted on the side of the dashboard using mounts from brodit.nu, and it turned out to be vital for the trip, providing both guidance and night sleeping spot recommendations.

This is by no means a scientific and full test of all the programs. I am not a paid reporter who has weeks to spare for fun stuff like that. I have done thorough research of currently available and popular apps, and tried to test most of them from my perspective of going to Morocco.

Web mgmt means you can set up and edit a route on your computer and automatically pick it up in the app
Rating is my very subjective rating, and it can change as I test the applications deeper.

Tested home means I have tested if it works and the looks, but not for a long trip.
The ratings are highly subjective and may change when I try the app more

UPDATE: We are now home again, and the clear winners during the trip were: For online use: Google Maps and Waze. For offline navigation between two addresses: Maps.me. For offline navigation on a route on roads: Navigon Europe. For offline navigation without roads: Locus Maps and Gaia GPS.

Updated 2017-11-01 20:25

Program
iPad
Android
Offline
Web mgmt
Navigation
Cost
Map source
Comments
Tested
Rating
Used on trip
WikiLoc
-
Y
Y
(Y)
-
Free
OSM
Detailed offline maps. Save tracks (search on website) and follow in car. Record own tracks.
Yes
5
Yes
Maps.me
Y
Y
Y
-
Y
Free
OSM
Simple navigation capabilities
Yes
5
Yes
Google Maps
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Free
Google
Some navigation incorrect
Yes
5
Yes
Waze
Y
Y
-
Map edit
Y
Free
Waze
Worldwide
Yes
4
Yes
Navigon Europe
Y
Y
Y
-
Y
$100
Navigon
Europe only
Yes
5
Yes
Locus Map Pro
-
Y
Y
-

3 maps free
OSM+SwissTopo+Outdooractive
Download GPX coordinates (from e.g. iOverlander)
Yes
5
Yes
Gaia GPS
Y
Y
Y

Y
$60
Gaia
Extremely slow map download. Needed 6 separate downloads for Morocco alone
Yes
4
Yes
OfflineMaps
Y

Y

-

?
There was a special map for Morocco, so I'll try it out
No

No
Soviet Military Maps app
-
Y
Y

-

Soviet Military
I'll bring it as a backup
No

No
CoPilot GPS
Y
Y
Y
-
Y
Free+$1-$40/map
Own?
Horrible interface on tablet. Not good and led us wrong (old maps?) Didn't like it at all. Choose Navigon instead.
Yes
2
Yes
iOverlander
Y
Y
-

-

?
Useful locations such as camping sites, mechanics and water. No navigation
Yes
4
Yes
Park4Night
Y
Y
Y
-
-
Free

Great complement to iOverlander
Yes
5
Yes
SearchForSites
Y
Y
-


Free

Complement to iOverlander. Web app
Yes
4
Yes
HERE WeGo
Y
Y
Y
-
Y
Free
Own
Not for Morocco
Yes

No
Avenza
Y
Y
Y
-
-
Free
Many

Yes

No












Map of Morocco offline

Y
Y

-
Free
?
Play Store link. Good reviews.


No
Rever
-
Y
Y
Y

Free
?
A bit complicated. Can't skip waypoints. Can't change routing in app?
Yes
3
No
PocketEarth
Y
-
Y


$2-$15
OSM
GPX Download possible. First 3 maps free. Weird location names in the Morocco map. Same map source as Viewranger?
Yes

No
Be-On-Road
Y
Y
Y



OSM
Updated 2015 (Apple)
Using OpenStreetMap.org
Rudimentary maps, and childish interface. Few settings


No
TopoGPS
Y
Y
Y


$1-$30
?
Doesn't seem to have Morocco


No
Sygic Morocco
Y
Y


Y
$40 (iPad)
TomTom


2
No
Navitel
Y
Y
Y

Y
$13-
OSM?
Europe & Russia, Iran and near Eastern. Seems great - but no Morocco maps

4
No
ViewRanger
Y
Y
Y
(Y)

Free ($100/topo map)
OSM + own topo
Detailed topographic maps for 23 countries
Yes
4
No
Lokalsinne
-
Y
Y
-
-
Free
Lantmäteriet
Sweden only


No
MapOut
Y
-
Y
-
-
$8
?




OruxMaps
-
Y
Y
-
-
$5
?

Yes

No
MotionXGps
Y
-
Y
-
-
$4
9 different




TomTom
Y
Y
Y


Free, $10-30





OSM = OpenStreetMap

Garmin MapSource format maps for Morocco: http://www.island-olaf.de/travel/marokko/gps.html
Comparison Gaia GPS vs. Motion-X: https://blog.gaiagps.com/gaia-gps-vs-motion-x/
More suggested apps for Android (BackCountry Navigator, HERE WeGo, MapFactor, MapQuest, Polaris Navigation and more) : http://www.androidauthority.com/best-gps-app-and-navigation-app-for-android-357870/


PLEASE let me know if you find any errors in the table!

2 comments:

  1. You can always load OSM maps by country in your Garmin (I am not sure if yours can support them though) by downloading the .img file through here: http://garmin.openstreetmap.nl/. You just load it in your SD card. BTW, the selection of the apps you have is brilliant. Thanks for enriching the community with such info.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the comment! Maybe I was unclear, but I don't have a Garmin or dedicated GPS. I was choosing between using Sony Xperia Z4 Tablet and an iPad Air for navigation when I did the chart. I have settled for the more configurable and open Android powered Z4 Tablet.

      Delete